Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Behaviorism in Practice


In the first two weeks of my current grad course - Bridging Learning Theory, Instruction, and Technology - we have explored the brain and the process of learning, as well as the differences between instructional theories and learning theories.  This week, we focused on the behaviorist theory of learning.

At its core, behaviorism is both a powerful strategy for managing behavior in the classroom as well as a method for teaching new skills through repetition and frequent practice (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011).  My goal has been to find out how behaviorism relates to instructional strategies… specifically those that integrate technology.

So how does behaviorism relate to technology?  Let’s look at reinforcing effort in the classroom as a jumping-off point.  We know that, even as adults, our participation and effort is greatly increased when we are provided with feedback and/or reinforcement.  Would I post to this blog if I knew that no one would ever respond to my posts?  It would be difficult, and far-less motivating.  The instructional strategy of reinforcing effort enhances students’ understanding of the relationship between effort and achievement by addressing their attitudes and beliefs about learning (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011).  Behaviorism is based on the assumption that reinforcement is central to explaining the learning process (Smith, 2007).  So providing reinforcement for student achievement is critical to student success.  Teachers can use technology tools (i.e. Excel, Word, Spreadsheet) to create charts and graphs for tracking student progress.  By displaying results on the classroom SMART Board or even on a class website, students are reinforced by knowing their positive efforts are visible to others.  By using survey tools or teacher-made “effort rubrics” (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, and Malenoski, 2007), students can clearly see what it takes to be successful in class.    

Let’s talk about homework.  The giving of homework continues to be a hot topic amongst educators and parents.  Some do not see the value of homework, looking at is as mindless, busy work.  So how does giving homework to our students relate to behaviorism?  A key characteristic of behaviorism is repetition and frequent practice of skills (Smith, 2007).  As an extension of the classroom, homework provides opportunities for students to deepen their understanding of the content and to gain proficiency with their skills (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, and Malenoski, 2007).  This is key to the efficacy of homework.  It cannot be utilized to teach brand new skills.  In relation to behaviorism, it should be used to drill and practice skills that have been previously learned.  Multiple exposures of material help students deepen their understanding of content (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, and Malenoski, 2007).  With technology, review of content is widely available and in a variety of contexts.  When we think of drills, most of us first think of math facts.  There is a multitude of websites (IXL is awesome!) and apps (Splash Math for iPad) that offer math skills practice that are both hands-on and motivating for students.  Technology also makes is easy for students, teachers, and parents to instantly track progress - further integrating a behavioristic approach (immediate feedback is so reinforcing!).  Besides math, there are sites that offer tutorials, practice problems, and games for all subject areas and grade levels (Fact Monster and BrainPop are two of my favorites).  I also love to create SMART Board activities that provide students with immediate feedback for correct answers.  There are thousands of pre-made activities and lessons for every grade-level and subject available on the SMART Exchange site.

After doing my research this week on behaviorism and its role in instruction, I firmly believe that it has a place in all classrooms.  Technology is an excellent and necessary tool for its integration. The key is for behaviorism to be looked at as a supplement to learning – not as the sole source for instruction in the classroom.  It can also play a critical role in providing students with feedback needed for motivation and success.  As teachers, we must ensure that behaviorism-based technology is utilized appropriately – both as a reinforcement strategy and a tool for the practice and guided instruction of specific content. 


Want to learn more about behaviorism?  Here’s a short, funny video on vimeo:

 Still not convinced that behaviorism has a place in the classroom?  
Paul Melrose’s blog post title caught my eye!




References
Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2011). Program four: Behaviorist learning theory [Video webcast]. Bridging learning theory, instruction and technology. Retrieved from http://laureate.ecollege.com/ec/crs/default.learn?CourseID=5700267&CPURL=laureate.ecollege.com&Survey=1&47=2594577&ClientNodeID=984650&coursenav=0&bhcp=1

Pitler, H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007). Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.

Smith, K. (1999).  The behaviourist orientation to learning.  In The encyclopedia of informal education.  Retrieved from http://www.infed.org/biblio/learning-behaviourist.htm

5 comments:

  1. Great post! "We know that, even as adults, our participation and effort is greatly increased when we are provided with feedback and/or reinforcement." How true -- it is easy to forget that even as adults, we respond and change our behavior according to positive or negative reinforcement.

    Do you find reinforcement to be even more important in the special education realm? What is your grade level and specialization? (I could look at our introductions...but I'm too tired!)

    Do you find independent homework to be a challenge? What works for you and your students? Does the technology piece motivate them?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mary,
      I teach a middle school unit for students with multiple disabilities (grades 6-8). And yes, reinforcement is critical in my classroom! I have students with varying behaviorial needs and on specific behavior plans. At the beginning of the year, I always get a list of reinforcers from parents (computer time, tangible rewards, etc.) in order to find out what is most rewarding to students. I also use a variety of visual reinforcements (First/Then schedules, sticker charts) to assist students in managing their own behavior.

      Due to the spectrum of ability levels in my class, it is not always appropriate (or beneficial) to give independent homework. I assign it on an individual basis. If students are unable to complete homework independently, I will sometimes give guided homework assignments (like a short story that parents can read with their child). I also like to share technology resources, like websites and apps, so parents can have their child work on math facts, time-telling, counting money, etc. (all the skills that need repetition and frequent practice - behaviorism in action!). And yes, technology is a huge motivator for them! We have classroom iPads as well as a SMART Board that is used throughout each school day. Technology is so incredibly engaging and hands-on... it's a MUST for instruction.

      Thanks for the reply :)

      Delete
  2. Rachel,
    Once again, you have provided us with a great post! I love how you always take the time to add an image to your post, and it really gets my attention.

    Behaviorism definitely is present in today's classrooms and in life in general. I believe that many actions are learned based upon consequences (or lack there of). Just as we are going to learn not to put our hand on a hot stove, we also learn that skipping homework and assignments has a negative effect on our grades.

    Reinforcing effort really can come in many forms. Simply posting answers to an Edmodo forum gives the students a greater purpose than writing an answer on a piece of paper for only the teacher to see.

    I used to have a sticker chart in my room for those students who had gotten an A on their spelling test for the week. I got called into the principal's office about this because it "might make some kids feel bad". However, I had carefully monitored my students' needs, adjusted lists as needed and many of the kids were successful. When I discussed with my class that we would no longer be able to have the sticker chart on the wall for everyone to see they were devastated! Even the parents contacted me, with concerns that their child wouldn't study once the chart had been taken down. I referred them to the principal and after a couple of weeks, our chart was back up and active again. We even started one for multiplication facts in the 3rd grade and once students mastered their 5's for example, they got a sticker. What a great way to get students to want to work hard and learn more facts.

    Thanks again for another wonderful post and for all of the great links you provided! Well done!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mindy,
      It's always nice to get your positive replies, thank you! :)

      I am glad you were able to reinstate the sticker charts in your classroom - it seems like they were a huge motivator for your kiddos! I have seen in other classrooms where each student is assigned a number, then the numbers are what is posted on the classroom wall chart (instead of names). Students can keep track of their success, but no one can be singled out by name for lack of effort. The students also get excited about their "secret number". If administration ever gives you a hard time again about having your charts, maybe this could work for you!

      Delete
  3. Hi Rachel,

    Thanks for your thoughts – I enjoyed your post.

    As you mentioned, homework is a hot topic these days. Every school needs to define its purpose for homework and define what is appropriate for each level, which you alluded to in your post. I sat on a committee years ago that developed a homework policy for our elementary school and we looked at a pile of research along with the homework policies for a number of large districts in North America and schools around the world. One research study we found in a book by Robert Marzano and Debra Pickering called Classroom Instruction that Works, quantified the effect of homework on achievement and found very different results from elementary to middle to high school. As a fifth grade teacher, I was focused on what the research showed for elementary students. The effect on achievement was negligible. The study concluded that the greatest gains caused by homework were found in high school. However, many other studies and anecdotes showed that homework can have an adverse effect on learning if we are not purposeful in how we approach it and assess it.

    That being said, I give homework to my fifth graders. I ask my students to do nightly self-selected reading for about 20-30 minutes and then conference with them on a rotating schedule so that I can give them feedback and evaluate their comprehension and use of strategies. I also target math skills appropriate for each student with IXL (I agree – it’s pretty nice for targeted practice) a couple of times per week. IXL allows for a differentiated form of math homework, rather than a one-size fits all worksheet. It also provides immediate feedback to users. Journal entries and blog posts are also individualized ways to practice and reflect on learning.

    I agree with you that homework has a place in education for the practice of skills. In many cases, we can provide our students opportunities for further exploration and enrichment through the use of some the technology tools available. If we are purposeful about assigning homework and allow for student choice, we can help them build a positive attitude towards homework.

    Thanks for letting me opine about homework. How do you approach homework with your students?

    Thanks again for your thoughtful post.

    ReplyDelete